Donald Trump’s White House Press Ruling Comes With a Catch for CNN

4 weeks ago 55

Donald Trump has faced another legal setback over his administration’s restrictions on news organizations. A federal judge ruled that journalists from CNN, MS NOW, and Politico should retain access to the White House. However, the decision does not automatically lift every restriction facing the outlets.

CNN and Politico still face Air Force One access restrictions after White House court ruling

U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly issued a preliminary injunction on October 13, as reported by Axios. The ruling extends protections established through his earlier emergency order. Those protections will remain in place until a final judgment unless an appeals court intervenes.

Kelly found Trump likely acted unlawfully when attempting to exclude the three news organizations. He said the president’s public remarks indicated that dissatisfaction with their reporting motivated the ban. The judge characterized the decision as “unlawful viewpoint discrimination.”

The dispute began in September, when Trump announced the restrictions on social media. He claimed CNN, Politico, and MS NOW should not report what he called “FICTION and LIES.” The outlets argued that the administration retaliated against them for unfavorable coverage.

Their lawsuit alleged violations of constitutional protections for free speech and a free press. They also challenged the administration’s treatment of journalists on due process grounds. The Justice Department, meanwhile, defended the restrictions on national security grounds.

Kelly rejected the administration’s explanation as the apparent reason for the original ban. He wrote that Trump’s own remarks suggested his complaints about coverage motivated the decision. However, the judge acknowledged that the president’s criticisms were not necessarily without merit.

“Simply put, that is unlawful viewpoint discrimination,” Kelly wrote in his decision. His ruling followed a hearing held on October 8. Attorneys for the outlets argued that the restrictions sought to influence reporting.

The outlets’ lawyer, Theodore Boutrous, accused the president of wanting to “coerce better coverage.” Justice Department attorney Michael Velchik countered that the organizations had engaged in “apparently indefensible conduct.” The competing arguments highlight the administration’s ongoing dispute with the press.

The preliminary injunction keeps the journalists’ White House access protections in place for now. However, the ruling does not settle the broader legal fight permanently. Restrictions on CNN and Politico’s access to Air Force One remain a separate concern despite the court’s decision.

The case also carries political significance ahead of the November 3 midterm elections. The lawsuit could further influence how the administration handles news organizations it criticizes. For now, the court’s intervention limits Trump’s ability to exclude these outlets from White House grounds.

Read Entire Article
Comment Box is loading comments...